note: I haven’t read any other reviews yet, so I’m sure mine will be similar to others. Also, I’ve only so far, seen part one. That might of been enough for me :\ edit: I did watch the second half. It was worse than the first half. More on that later.
For starters, I’ll call it ‘A&E’s “Bag of Bones” ‘ because I’m pretty sure that what I watched was NOT Stephen King’s “Bag of Bones”. It sure as hell wasn’t the “Bag of Bones” I read. I at least don’t blame Stephen King so much, as he’s not the one who did the screenplay. He should of tho, it probably would of been at least a little more correct.
Oh, where to begin?
((I swear I won’t begin with the out of sequence-ness…))
I’ll start with Mike Noonan’s book title “They All Fall Down” ?? …yeah, the one they show at the book signing…Wait, what book signing? Yeah, I know.
Jo writing the last lines of Mike’s book…they couldn’t of at least had her type the same stuff??
Also, the book titles that “Marty” ((wait, you mean, Harold?? )) is talking about in the cemetery… Oh, I’m sorry, but Mike Noonan didn’t write those books. At least, not in the book that I read.
I know for a fact that I’m not just being picky here…Jo got hit by a bus? No she bloody did not. I figured on that point, they were going for shock value….pretty lady coming across the street and then BAM! I’m pretty sure they could of been just as detailed with a brain aneurysm. I mean, hell, it worked in the book.
Mike sitting in a bar with…Sid? My memory says he was sitting with Frank Arlen. I’ll give them almost a point for using *some* correct dialog there. But then, they had to go and have Mike say that if they were having a boy, they would of named him Mike Jr. ((the book says Andrew)) and that their daughter would of been Kia Jo. ((again, book says Kia Jane))
That irritated me, but not as much as the whole story about Mike inheriting the lake house. WTF?!?!?!
“Last night I dreamed I went to Dark Score lake again”. “Last night I dreamed I went to Manderley again”. I suppose they’re supposed to mean the same thing…if that’s the case, just say “Manderley”.
I had a bit of hope with the dream when he sees the coffin…then, I got over it, and thought about how the coffin is supposed to be at the end of the drive…and a white shroud thing comes out of the house, shrieking. There’s not supposed to be a coffin in the woods with a friggin phone in it. Really? And certainly, Kyra Devore isn’t supposed to show up in those dreams, either…
Ugh.
So, Mike gets to Sara Laughs. ((I’ve only seen part 1 once so far, but I don’t think they referred to the house as Sara Laughs…nor did they call the town TR-90)) And Bill Dean is on the porch? Wait, rewind. He gets a phone call from a guy *introducing* himself as Bill Dean. Oh, hell no. So, what, now Mike doesn’t even *know* Bill?? Right, so…Bill Dean on the front porch…Did they forget that he doesn’t show up until the next day or so…it’s a Monday when he shows up, I know that…? Did they forget that Mike plans his arrival time at Sara to match the dreams he’s been having? ((Why yes, yes they did))
So, because they decided to make it so that Bill and Mike don’t know each other, I guess that had to make it so Mike didn’t know Brenda Meserve, either.
((But, they point out later on that Jo knew Bill and his wife, and she also knew Brenda Meserve, too))
Blah blah blah, Mike is looking around the house…and goes right out to Jo’s studio? Actually, I think he was supposed to look around a bit, and then, hear the sound of a kid screaming…which he eventually attributes to air in the pipes. Visiting the studio is happens on another day entirely…((if my memory is correct.))
((Also, did anyone else think that the movie Mike…uh, wallowed around too much? I mean, yes, in the book, Mike is heartbroken, but he doesn’t hang around the house listening to his wife’s voicemail all day…I said it before, but Pierce Brosnan was the total wrong person for the role, and I was totally right.))
Soooo….trip out to the studio the night he arrives…weird flashbacks while looking at Sara’s portrait…lol. Really?
Attempt #1 for Mike trying to write: Can you tell me how him sitting there drinking and yelling at his computer is more interesting than a full blown panic attack? Panic attacks are soo scary, and the fact that Mike can’t write because of these is so crippling to him…But, the movie shows it as being, well, not a super *super* huge deal…
Mike meets Brenda…ok…and he asks her for a recommendation on where to eat? She says Buddy Jellisons, and Mike is all ‘wha???’
((I thought after his morning run, he thought he’d head down to the Cafe for a Villageburger…because not many tourists went there…He usually takes a counter seat, but he decides on a booth instead…Noting, as he had before, the dirtiness of Buddy’s cooks whites, and the cleanliness of his nails…Saying that Audrey short orders but doesn’t waitress.)) But first, he meets Kyra Devore.
I said initally when I saw the promo photos, that the girl they were using was too old. Fine, I could probably get over that, I understand. However, Mattie comes *running around the corner* ?!?!?! Where’s Scoutie? Put her in any vehicle then if you’re not going to use a Jeep just don’t make her come RUNNING. That was just ridiculous. Yes, Mattie does say to Mike ((in the book))
“…You don’t know how bizarre this is for me. One of my favorite writers comes out of nowhere and saves my kid. I knew you had a place on the TR, that big old log house everyone calls Sara Laughs, but folks say you don’t come here much since your wife died.”
*But*, she isn’t supposed to get all fangirl on him. Yes, she’s supposed to be like *wow*, but not fangirling…she’s upset, or, she’s supposed to be upset.
What are these people doing??
I did nothing but shake my head during that part…I really just couldn’t get over the lameness of it…
Enter Buddy’s Cafe…Why oh why must you be like that Mr. Screenplay writer man??? Mattie Devore killed Lance because he snapped and tried to drown Kyra and *that’s* why Max wants custody??? omfg. Do they think we don’t remember that Lance was on the roof of his and Mattie’s trailer, putting up the satellite dish, finishing before the storm hit…And then he realized a bit after that he left his socket wrench up there…While coming down the ladder, lightning strikes close by where he is, scaring him, and he fell off the ladder and broke his neck. Also, that Devore had been trying to buy Mattie off a couple times while she was still pregnant, not just after the baby was born.
…I might be skipping forward here, but I suppose it hardly matters.
They show Mike in the basement, because he hears…music? I thought he was heading down there to look for the owls Bill was supposed to mention? And on his way down there, he felt like he wasn’t alone: it was much colder down there than it should of been…Tap once for yes, twice for no on the insulation…But *music playing*?? It’s supposed to be creepy. I get it. So, he goes downstairs and finds…a record by Sara Tidwell?
Sara Tidwell, known as Sara Laughs. Never recorded, but her songs had lived just the same.
Guys, come on, you’re killing me here.
And now, I’m going to cut short, because I have to get ready for work… And later tonite, after my kids basketball games, I’ll watch part two, maybe.
I’ll say this about what I saw in part one: If you’ve never read the book, then it was probably a good movie. If you’ve read the book more than once, or at least remember *all* of it, do you agree with what they did??
Yeah. I don’t.
Until…later…
<333
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.